4

As gleaned from a comment to a different meta question, I learned that close votes "expire" after a certain time period. It appears, though, that those who have voted to close a question are then prevented from voting again. Attempting to cast a close vote after the initial vote has expired results in a "you have already voted to close this question" message.

Is this expected/normal behavior? If so, it really makes appropriate community moderation difficult. See for example this question: Is file_exists() compatible with timthumb.php?

Obviously, it should be closed (TimThumb & is_file_exists() - completely agnostic to WordPress), but it never did get closed. But I cast a close vote a year ago, and now can't again.

| |
  • 2
    I think this is one of those cases when logic scaled to larger network sites doesn't work too well for the rest. – Rarst Feb 6 '13 at 14:35
  • So, what do we do about it - or, more specifically: how do we work around this network limitation? – Chip Bennett Feb 6 '13 at 15:03
  • +1 and: You should add feature-request – kaiser Feb 6 '13 at 15:17
1

From What Happened Here? Voted to Close 4 Days Ago, but No Close Votes Today?:

We now use a form of sliding expiration, so as long as close/reopen votes keep arriving at the rate of at least one every 4 days, they will not expire.

Once the votes do expire, vote aging happens every 24 hours, so you can expect the remaining very old close/reopen votes to expire at the rate of 1 per day after that, unless of course someone casts another close/reopen vote in which case the expiration timer resets to 4 days.

Also, if the question has <= 100 views, no expiration on close (or reopen) votes is done at all.

There are two solutions. Well, maybe …

  1. Encourage our members to visit the review queue for closed questions more often. But how?
  2. Ask the SE team to implement this rule on our site:

Close votes (and probably reopen votes) only expire after all of these conditions are met:

  1. 4 days have passed since the last close vote.
  2. The question has more than 100 views.
| |

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .