I asked this question handling login/logout redirects It was helpful and what I wanted and it will probably help someone else.
However the comments have devolved and gone off-topic and not really what I would want anyone else to see.
The fact that some feel they don't agree with my opinions about not wanting to use a lot of plugins for a few minor features (Which I didn't even ask about or imply for that matter, not until someone asked.) doesn't mean I don't have the right to ask for a different solution just like I can't tell someone what they should or shouldn't answer. Right?
Someone was so incensed at my preference for a coded solution he even edited out the reference to it in my question!
It's partly my fault, I shouldn't have continued the conversation. I have a hard letting go :)
Should I leave or delete my question or can the comments be moderated by someone else somehow?