I was about to post a question requesting help finding a theme that matches certain criteria, but felt like it might be borderline off-topic and might be construed as a poll question. Clearly if I worded it like "Whats a good theme for my blog?" it should get closed quickly, but if I am very specific about my requirements it seems like more of a gray area.
Before I submitted it I thought I'd ask the meta-community if it is acceptable.
Here's a pro-forma example of the type of question I am asking about
I've been looking for a new theme for my WP blog and finding the search functionality lacking on many of the theme marketplaces and theme vendor sites. Can you recommend a theme that meets these criteria?
- Three column
- Liquid/flexible layout
- Prominent commenting features
- Layout to display one blog post per page
- Custom header banner image support
- Tabbed layout.
I realize I could just post the question and throw it to the wolves to devour or adopt and raise with the pack. However, I thought it worth discussion as to whether highly specific theme recommendation requests are on topic for the site.