3

Often, a question is asked here in Meta, and the initial answer begins with, "this question was asked on Meta.SO, and the accepted answer was..." (with a link to the referenced question.

I question whether we should rely on/default to the accepted answers to similar/related Meta.SO questions. Let's discuss.

| |
4

Meta.WPSE should not rely on/default to the accepted answer to similar/related questions on Meta.SO.

While site mechanics and conventions are consistent across all SE network sites, each site is different, meets different needs, serves different communities, deals with different types of questions, and is comprised of different users with differing expertise levels. What is appropriate/works well for the SO community may or may not work well for the WPSE community.

Currently, Meta.SO questions are linked, with the implication that the Meta.SO community's accepted answer should be our starting point, further implying that we would need a convincing argument to decide differently from that community. I would prefer to see references to related/similar Meta.SO questions posed as neutral, along the lines of, "here's how the Meta.SO community discussed this question", in the chance that the perspectives, issues, and arguments posed by that community might be constructive to our community's discussion.

| |
  • Wholeheartedly agree. – EAMann May 14 '12 at 17:21

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .